As it is true for so many immigrant families of the 20th century, life was defined by hard work and sacrifice. My own grandparents, who emigrated from Italy to New York City, worked hard to enable their children to seek education and opportunities in life. Similarly, a few hundred miles to the north, two other Italian immigrants were raising their children. One of their sons, Francesco Caprio, known as Frank, would go on to impact the lives of many people in a positive way. Frank was born in 1936, and went on to earn a bachelor’s degree and later his law degree in Boston. With God’s blessing, the support of his parents and his own hard work, Frank became a municipal judge in Providence Rhode Island in 1985. That was not particularly noteworthy—what was significant was the type of judge Frank Caprio became.
Judge Caprio invited his dad, a grocer and fruit peddler, to his courtroom for his first day on the bench. A young mother of 3 came before him with several municipal violations. When she could not adequately explain the reason for the violations, Judge Caprio levied a harsh penalty on her. In his chambers following Court, he asked his father how he did. He anticipated that his dad was going to praise his son. After all, he had worked hard to earn his degrees and his seat as a judge. Rather than praising, he expressed his shock and disappointment with the harsh treatment that his son had shown to the young woman. Judge Caprio defended himself: “But Dad, she broke the law, was arrogant and would not try to explain herself!” His father did not hesitate in telling his son that the woman was obviously terrified at being in the courtroom with her three children, and rather than showing compassion, his son chose the harshest punishment available. His father went on to explain to his son that the woman was so afraid that she could not speak, let alone attempt to explain the reason for the violations.
Decades later, Judge Caprio shared in an interview that this moment altered him. He never again wanted to disappoint his father by being the harsh, unforgiving person his dad had seen in action. He understood, that for so many residents of his small New England city, he was perhaps the only part of the government that people would interact with. He learned to show compassion, empathy, and to try to understand what the person in front of him was dealing with in life.
Judge Caprio became well-known as a compassionate and well-loved jurist. While he still held people to account for infractions, he sought to understand them and to give them the opportunity to correct their poor choices. If a defendant had ten dollars in his or her pocket and the fine of $10 would leave them without any resources, Judge Caprio would either reduce the fine, or, if the situation warranted, he’d pay the fine from a fund established in his mother’s name. He helped young, old, veterans, and struggling students and immigrants to understand that violating the law had consequences, but that they needed to change their motivation and do better.
Consider the parable of the Lost Son in Luke 15:11-31. The son said to his father: “I have sinned against heaven and in your sight, and am no longer worthy to be called your son.” The father in this situation could have imposed a harsh punishment on his errant son, but he realized that his son had suffered and had learned that his profligate ways had been sinful against God and his father’s authority. Instead of further punishment, his father celebrated his return to the family and also to God.
Consider also God’s mercy with His disobedient people when in 586 B.C., He allowed the Babylonian army to destroy the temple and persecute His people. Still, God was compassionate, as we read in the Book of Lamentations, 3:22-24: “Through the LORD’S mercies we are not consumed, Because His compassions fail not. They are new every morning; Great is Your faithfulness. The LORD is my portion, says my soul, Therefore I hope in Him.”
If God can be merciful and allow for second and many more chances to repent, can we not find a similar compassion? God will always renew His mercy towards us if we sincerely repent. David reflected on this in Psalm 103:10-12: “He has not dealt with us according to our sins, Nor punished us according to our iniquities. For as the heavens are high above the earth, So great is His mercy toward those who fear Him; As far as the east is from the west, So far has He removed our transgressions from us.”
Judge Caprio died in 2025 and continues to be mourned by the many people whose lives he touched. For true Christians, our Father is relentless in His mercy and compassion if we correct our sinful ways. His mercy endures—what about our compassion?
